Renting vs. Buying in Seattle: Navigating the Ongoing Debate

Seattle’s dynamic housing market has become a hotbed for the ongoing “rent vs. buy” debate. With soaring home prices, robust job opportunities, and an ever-growing population, many locals are weighing the costs—and benefits—of owning a home versus staying in a rental. While current market conditions make renting look more cost-effective in many cases, there are still compelling reasons why homeownership can be worth considering for those who can make it work.

Why Renting May “Feel Like” the Safer Bet Right Now

Lower Monthly Outlay
One study found that in Seattle, the monthly cost to buy a starter home was 61% higher than renting a similar property—about a $2,222 difference each month. With rents stabilizing or even dipping slightly in some neighborhoods, many see renting as the more budget-friendly option, at least in the short term.

Flexibility in a Changing Job Market
The Seattle area is home to numerous tech giants, and periodic market shifts—including layoffs—can make it daunting to lock into a mortgage. Renting allows individuals to move more easily for new opportunities or to adjust their housing expenses without the added complications of selling a home.

Focus on Savings
For some renters, the monthly savings compared to a mortgage can be channeled into building a down payment fund or emergency savings. With interest rates still elevated relative to past years, this can be a strategic way to prepare for a future home purchase once conditions become more favorable.

Why Buying Can Still Be a Smart Move

Building Equity
While renting can free up monthly cash flow, buying a home enables you to build equity over time. Every mortgage payment made toward the principal increases your stake in a tangible asset. When the day comes to sell, that accumulated equity can often be leveraged into your next home or other financial goals.

Fixed Monthly Payments
Unlike rent, which can rise with market conditions or landlord decisions, a fixed-rate mortgage (once secured) provides predictability in your monthly payment. Over the long term, this stability can be a major advantage, especially in a region where rents could trend upward.

Potential for Appreciation
Historically, Seattle’s real estate market has demonstrated strong growth, although no one can guarantee future performance. If demand for housing continues to outstrip supply, homeowners may benefit from price appreciation, which can boost equity faster than paying down the mortgage alone.

Freedom to Personalize
Owning your home means you can remodel, landscape, or decorate any way you choose—no need to ask a landlord for permission. This freedom can enhance your quality of life and potentially increase the home’s value over time.

Finding Balance: When Does It Make Sense to Buy?

Despite current market challenges, many first-time buyers are adopting a “watchful waiting” approach. They continue to rent but closely monitor mortgage rates, new property developments, and any changes in home prices. Here are a few factors to consider if you’re on the fence:

  • Your Financial Health: Before jumping into homeownership, ensure you have a solid emergency fund and manageable debt.
  • Long-Term Outlook: If you plan to stay in Seattle for several years, the benefits of buying—equity building, stability, and potential appreciation—may outweigh the short-term costs.
  • Future Rate Changes: If interest rates decline, refinancing could potentially lower your monthly payment, making homeownership more affordable later on.
  • Market Shifts: Stay informed about new construction projects or price dips in areas you like. The Seattle market evolves quickly, and opportunities can arise in certain neighborhoods.

How we can help!

Navigating Seattle’s competitive housing market can be complex. At David Haley Mortgage, Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation, our goal is to provide personalized insights to help you determine whether renting or buying is right for your unique circumstances. From exploring different loan products to calculating potential monthly payments, we’re here to support you every step of the way.

  • Tailored Mortgage Options: We’ll discuss your financial goals and help you understand the range of products that may be available.
  • Financial Guidance: Our team aims to simplify complex mortgage concepts, so you can make decisions with greater clarity.
  • Local Expertise: We know the greater Seattle area inside and out. We can offer perspective on neighborhood trends, market conditions, and factors that influence home values.

The “rent vs. buy” debate in Seattle reflects both the city’s rising living costs and the long-term allure of homeownership. While renting can offer short-term financial relief and flexibility, owning a home can yield valuable benefits such as equity growth and payment stability. Ultimately, the right decision comes down to your personal financial situation, career plans, and comfort level with the responsibilities of ownership.

If you’re weighing the pros and cons of renting versus buying, consider reaching out to a trusted mortgage professional for guidance. At David Haley Mortgage, we’re dedicated to helping you chart the best path forward for your specific needs—so you can move confidently toward the future in Seattle’s vibrant housing market.

This content is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. Always consult a qualified professional for guidance specific to your situation.

Should You Wait Until Interest Rates Drop?

Waiting for a lower rate might slightly reduce your monthly payment, but rising home prices and lost equity-building opportunities often outweigh the benefit. Buying sooner allows you to lock in your home’s price and start building long-term wealth. Plus, if rates drop later, you can always explore refinancing to lower your payment—while rent typically keeps increasing.

Meet Sarah, a first-time homebuyer. She is looking at a $500,000 home. At a 7%* interest rate on a 30-year mortgage, her monthly principal and interest payment would be around $3,326*. She thinks about waiting a year, hoping rates drop to 6%*. At 6%*, the monthly payment on a $500,000 mortgage is about $2,998*—a clear savings.

But if prices rise in the meantime—say that $500,000 home jumps to $525,000—Sarah’s monthly payment at 6% becomes $3,147*, which is closer to what she would have paid at 7%* anyway. Meanwhile, she’s missed out on a year’s worth of potential equity and possibly paid rent instead.

Disclaimer: The values marked with * are rough estimates for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary based on individual circumstances, market conditions, loan terms, and other factors. This does not constitute financial advice—please consult a professional for precise calculations and guidance.

Opportunity for Growth: By purchasing now, Sarah locks in today’s home price and starts building equity right away. Even if rates drop later, she could refinance to secure a lower payment—but she won’t miss out on potential appreciation or continue throwing money at rent.

Opportunity Cost of Waiting: If Sarah waits and prices climb, that extra cost may offset—or even exceed—her savings from a slightly lower interest rate. Over the long term, missing out on appreciation and the chance to build home equity can be a bigger setback than paying a bit more in interest initially.

Unsure What’s Right for You?
At David Haley Mortgage, we help first-time buyers weigh the pros and cons of buying now vs. waiting—so you can make a smart choice for your future. Contact us today to explore your options!

Refinancing Your Home to Pay Off Student Loans: Key Benefits

Refinancing your home to pay off student loans offers a streamlined, cost-effective way to manage debt. Here’s why it’s a good idea:

  • One Monthly Payment: Combining student loans with your mortgage simplifies repayment, making budgeting easier.
  • Flexible Terms for Financial Relief: You can adjust the mortgage term to reduce monthly payments, freeing up cash for other priorities.
  • Potential Tax Savings: Mortgage interest may be tax-deductible, creating added financial benefits.

Watch the video below to hear David discuss how home refinancing can make tackling student debt simpler and more financially beneficial.

 
“Got 90 Seconds? Watch to Discover a Smarter Way to Pay Off Student Loans!”

Have you ever wondered how the Fed’s rate cuts impact mortgages? Does it really matter?

With the recent decision by the Federal Reserve to cut interest rates, many people are asking how this change affects their plans to buy a home or refinance. Whether you’re a first-time buyer or a homeowner considering refinancing, it’s important to understand how the Fed’s actions could impact your mortgage options — and whether it truly matters.

How the Fed’s Rate Cut Affects Mortgages

The Federal Reserve’s rate cuts don’t directly change mortgage rates, but they do influence them. Mortgage rates are tied to broader financial markets, and when the Fed lowers rates, it can create a ripple effect that often leads to more favorable conditions for homebuyers and refinancers. While mortgage rates may not drop immediately, they tend to stabilize or fall over time, making it easier for buyers to secure better terms.

Does It Really Matter?

The impact of the Fed’s rate cut depends on your timing and financial goals. If you’re looking to buy a home, this cut can give you an advantage by making borrowing conditions more favorable. However, it’s important to remember that mortgage rates are also influenced by other factors like your credit score, loan type, and the length of the loan. So while the Fed’s decision can make a difference, your financial situation plays an even bigger role in the terms you’re offered.

This is where having a knowledgeable loan officer can make a world of difference. Unlike large corporate programs that often focus on volume and overlook the finer details, we provide personalized guidance. Whether you’re ready to buy now or planning for the near future, we can help you uncover opportunities or create a roadmap to achieve your goals.

For Homebuyers: Why Now Might Be the Best Time

If you’ve been waiting to buy a home, the current conditions could present a great opportunity. The Fed’s rate cut has created an environment where borrowing could be more affordable. If you’ve found a home within your budget, now might be the time to move forward before market conditions shift again. Acting sooner could help you avoid rising competition for homes, as well as potential price increases.

With years of experience serving the local community, we understand the market in ways that large corporations might not. Our experience enables us to help you make sound decisions, ensuring you’re not just getting a loan, but finding the right loan that fits your long-term goals.

Refinancing: Evaluate Carefully

If you already own a home and are considering refinancing, the Fed’s move could work in your favor, but it’s important to evaluate your situation carefully. The key is to determine if refinancing will provide enough long-term savings to justify the costs involved. Your decision should also depend on how long you plan to stay in your current home. If you’re staying put for a while, refinancing could help lower your payments or offer better terms, but it’s essential to crunch the numbers first.

Working with us means benefiting from our personalized approach. We take pride in collaborating with clients repeatedly, ensuring that each refinance or mortgage is tailored to fit your needs — something big lenders might overlook as they focus on volume.

Strengthen Your Financial Standing

Whether buying or refinancing, preparing your finances is crucial. Improving your credit score by paying down debt can enhance your chances of securing better mortgage terms. Even though the Fed’s decision creates a more borrower-friendly environment, your personal financial profile is still a critical factor.

Our hands-on approach can guide you through this process, offering wisdom and insights that large lenders often miss. We are not just here to help you secure a loan today, but to ensure that you’re set up for success in the long term.

What’s Next?

At David Haley Mortgage, a branch of Fairway Independent Mortgage Corp, we’re here to help you navigate these changing conditions and make informed decisions based on your unique needs. Whether you’re purchasing a new home or refinancing your existing mortgage, understanding the potential impact of the Fed’s rate cut is key to making the best move. Contact us today to explore your options and take the next step toward your homeownership goals, with the personalized attention and care that only a local expert can offer.

Daniel’s Homebuying Adventure in Everett

Daniel is excited to buy his first home and has his heart set on Everett, a city known for its rapid development and diverse job opportunities. With a background in aerospace, he’s thrilled about the proximity to the Boeing company and many other aerospace companies all gathered around in the area. Daniel is also excited about the city’s plan to develop up to 15-story tall buildings in North Everett, which promises a modern lifestyle for young couples and professionals.

However, Daniel is new to the world of home buying and feels overwhelmed by the decision between purchasing and leasing. He knows that in Everett, both options have their pros and cons, and the right choice depends on his personal circumstances. Fortunately, he’s been recommended to talk to David Haley, a local expert who has been helping people buy homes in the area for almost two decades.

Illustration of man standing in front of a house for sale in Everett, Washington

Meeting David Haley

David listens to Daniel’s concerns about the current controversial interest rates and his desire for a manageable mortgage. He explains that not all mortgages are the same and introduces him to a 3/2/1 buydown mortgage, a special financing option that could be perfect for him.

Understanding the 3/2/1 Buydown Mortgage

David explains that a 3/2/1 buydown mortgage allows Daniel to pay lower interest rates in the first three years of his loan, gradually increasing to the standard rate in the fourth year and staying constant after that. Here’s how it breaks down:

  1. First Year: Daniel’s interest rate is 3% lower than the standard rate.
  2. Second Year: His interest rate is 2% lower than the standard rate.
  3. Third Year: His interest rate is 1% lower than the standard rate.
  4. Fourth Year and Beyond: He pays the standard rate.

How Does This Benefit Daniel?

David explains that this mortgage type can be especially beneficial in Everett’s evolving market. With the area’s development and job opportunities, Daniel can expect his income to increase over time, making it easier to handle higher payments in the future. Plus, the seller of his new home agrees to pay for the 3/2/1 buydown program, placing the funds in a special savings account to cover the reduced interest portions.

What if Interest Rates Go Down?

David also reassures Daniel that if interest rates drop in the next couple of years, he can refinance his mortgage. The money in the savings account set up by the seller can help cover the fees associated with refinancing, making the transition smooth and cost-effective.

Why Work with David Haley?

David’s expertise doesn’t end with finding the right mortgage. He’s known for thinking in his clients’ terms and enjoys educating first-time buyers like Daniel. His extensive knowledge of VA loans, conventional loans, and other financing options ensures that Daniel gets a mortgage tailored to his needs, not just what’s most profitable for lenders.

Thanks to David’s guidance, Daniel feels confident about purchasing his dream home in Everett. He appreciates having a trusted advisor who genuinely cares about his financial well-being and enjoys helping people become part of the Everett community.

With David Haley’s help, Daniel embarks on his homebuying journey with peace of mind, knowing he’s made a smart, informed decision for his future.

VA Loan – Risk Assessment

In case some of you were not able to make it to the online web discussion – here is one of the biggest items we targeted on. VA loan and Risk Assessments:

Last Week’s Questions & Answers: 12/20/2011

Q: Did you know that there have been updates in DU to the Credit Risk Assessment for VA Loan casefiles? 

A: During the weekend of  Dec. 17, 2011, there were updates to DU for VA loan casefiles and evaluating
credit risk assessment. You may see loans impacted as follows:

  • Overall improved credit characteristics for loan
    casefiles may receive an Approve recommendation
  • A change in the underwriting recommendation for some
    loan casefiles. For example, some loan casefiles that previously received an Approve recommendation may now receive a Refer recommendation, particularly ones with back-end debt-to-income ratios over 45%.
  • Reduced Approve recommendation rates. The overall
    reduction may vary by customer depending on the credit characteristics of the VA loan casefiles submitted to DU.

VA Loan casefiles created on or after the weekend of Dec 17, will be evaluated using the new credit risk assessment. In addition, VA loan casefiles created prior to Dec 17, and resubmitted to DU for any reason (i.e. change in appraised value) on or after the weekend of Dec 17, will be evaluated using the new credit risk assessment if there are any changes to any key credit characteristics of the loan casefile (e.g. LTV).

When we run to find out if a home buyer for a VA Loan will qualify we run it through an automated underwriting system. This will give us specific criteria and tolerances for our loan approvals.

Should you have any questions please contact me.

FHA Mortgage – Gift Funds – Bothell, Mill Creek, Lynnwood WA

Gift funds still allowed for Home Buyers seeking to become a home owner, with home prices that are compared to 2000-2003 prices, and with today’s low interest rates, often times you can get into a home lower than what your rent payments are.

Gift funds can come from family members and all that is needed is 3.5% for your down payment, so if you were to purchase a home for as little as 150,000.00 then you will only need: 5,250.00  as a gift down payment.

There are other ways that you can accomplish this down payment if you choose to not receive a gift from your family, you can take a loan on your 401k up to 10,000.00 when you are a First Time Home Buyer.

When you are ready to go out and begin the home search make sure you have your finances, credit, and employment all worked out, by this I mean get pre-approved before you take the step to go out and look for your home. You must know what your payment and debt to income ratios will be, as well as what you can truly afford.

Buying a home can be easy when you have the right steps done in the right order, believe me, make sure you know what you can truly afford before you go out looking for a home.

Stanwood-listing-003 Who can qualify for a FHA Home loan, just about anyone, you do not have to be a first time home buyer! If you have owned a home before that is fine, you can have one FHA loan at a time, is the main guideline, however some exceptions have been seen before.

So to quickly summarize you can still purchase a home Zero Down* if you do receive a Gift! Should you seek more information and want to know what you qualify for go to the top right side of the website, click “Apply Now” and put David Haley as the loan officer and I will be glad to help you get started to owning your new home!

FHA – Increase in Mortgage Insurance – No April Fools Joke!

April 1st of 2012 will not be a good April Fool’s joke – once again FHA has been looking at their overall solvency concerns and has deteremined they need to pass along the added costs to the new borrowers.

The UFMIP will be increased from 1 percent to 1.75 percent of the base loan amount.  This increase applies regardless of the amortization term or LTV ratio.  FHA will continue to permit financing of this charge into the mortgage.  This change is effective for case numbers assigned on or after April 1, 2012.  Example: Loan Amount = 100,000.00 new Upfront Mortgage Insurance Premium is 1.75% = 1,750.00 being financed into new loan.

The Temporary Payroll Tax Cut Continuation Act of 2011 requires FHA to increase the annual MIP it collects by 0.10 percent.  This change is effective for case numbers assigned on or after April 1, 2012.  FHA is also exercising its statutory authority to add an additional 0.25 percent to mortgages exceeding $625,500.  This change is effective for case numbers assigned on or after June 1, 2012. UPDATE: Here is the HUD LINK

So for quick examples and here is the easiest equation. Take  your loan amount 100,000.00 time new Monthly Mortgage Insurance Cost of 1.25% = 1,250.00 then divide this number by 12 to give you the Monthly Mtg Ins Premium Cost = 104.17 per month vs. the old MI factor of 1.15% = 1,150.00 / 12 = 95.83 per month.

Now these are all numbers based on if you are only putting the 3.5% minimum investment down for this type of loan.

Taken together, these premium changes will enable FHA to increase revenues at a time that is critical to the ongoing stability of its Mutual Mortgage Insurance (MMI) Fund, contributing more than $1 billion to the Fund, based on current volume projections through Fiscal Year 2013.

Should you have any questions please give contact me.

MI basics: tax-deductible MI

Untitled-7-01MI Tax Deductibility passed as part of the American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012.

Borrower-paid MI premiums are tax-deductible through the year 2013. Borrowers should consult their tax advisors regarding MI tax deductibility. See disclaimer note below.

FAQs

Does the bill apply to mortgage insurance?

Yes, borrower-paid MI provided by qualifies for the deduction. This includes the Monthly, Single and Split Premium plans. There are varied opinions on the deductibility of lender-paid MI as the IRS has not yet clarified the deductibility. It is recommended that borrowers consult their tax advisors regarding the amount that is deductible.

What types of mortgage loans qualify for the MI tax deduction?

Loans used for “acquisition indebtedness” — that is, money borrowed to buy, build or substantially improve a residence — are eligible, as long as the debt is secured by the same residence.

This includes purchase loans and refinance loans, up to the original acquisition indebtedness. (Money borrowed against the equity in a home or when refinancing a home for any reason other than to buy, build or substantially improve a residence is called “equity indebtedness.”)

When refinancing a piggyback loan originally used to acquire a property, is the original loan amount considered the sum of the two mortgages or only the primary mortgage amount without the second lien included?

The original acquisition indebtedness is considered to be the sum of the two mortgages.

Is deductibility applicable for all loan types?

There is no differentiation among loan types.

What types of properties are eligible for tax deductibility?

The deduction applies to “qualified residences,” as defined in the Internal Revenue Code. Generally, that includes the borrower’s primary residence and a non-rental second home. As with mortgage interest, borrowers can deduct mortgage insurance premiums paid on both their primary residence and one other qualified residence each year. Investor loans are not eligible.

Who qualifies for this itemized deduction?

Households with adjusted gross incomes of $100,000 or less will be able to deduct 100% of their MI premiums. The deduction is reduced by 10% for each additional $1,000 of adjusted gross household income, phasing out after $109,000. (Details below.)

Married individuals filing separate returns who have adjusted gross incomes of $50,000 or less will be able to deduct 50% of their MI premiums. The deduction is reduced by 5% for each additional $500 of adjusted gross income, phasing out after $54,500. (Details below.)

The deduction is not restricted to first-time homebuyers.

Adjusted Gross Income Limits
Single OR
Married, Filing
Jointly
Allowable
MI Premium Deduction
Married,
Filing
Separately
Allowable
MI Premium Deduction

$0 – $100,000

100%

$0 – $50,000

50%

$100,000.01 – $101,000

90%

$50,000.01 – $50,500

45%

$101,000.01 – $102,000

80%

$50,500.01 – $51,000

40%

$102,000.01 – $103,000

70%

$51,000.01 – $51,500

35%

$103,000.01 – $104,000

60%

$51,500.01 – $52,000

30%

$104,000.01 – $105,000

50%

$52,000.01 – $52,500

25%

$105,000.01 – $106,000

40%

$52,500.01 – $53,000

20%

$106,000.01 – $107,000

30%

$53,000.01 – $53,500

15%

$107,000.01 – $108,000

20%

$53,500.01 – $54,000

10%

$108,000.01 – $109,000

10%

$54,000.01 – $54,500

5%

 

Is adjusted gross income calculated before or after deductions?

Adjusted gross income is calculated before itemized deductions, including the MI deduction.

How does the MI tax deduction work?

Borrowers who itemize deductions are able to reduce their overall taxable income in the same manner as mortgage interest.

Are borrower-paid, single premiums, which are paid up front in a lump sum, eligible for the deduction?

Yes, borrower-paid, single-premiums are eligible for the deduction under the new law. Borrowers should consult with a professional tax advisor to determine the amount of the MI premium eligible for the tax deduction.

If the single premium is financed, are both the mortgage insurance premium and the interest tax deductible?

We believe that if the loan is for acquisition indebtedness, both the interest attributable to the entire loan balance as well as the allocated portion of the mortgage insurance premium is tax deductible.

How would a premium refund issued during the tax year affect eligibility and the amount of the MI deduction?

Borrowers are only permitted to deduct that portion of their MI premium attributable to a tax year. If the MI is dropped, and a refund is paid, the amount refunded would reduce the amount of MI premium that could be attributable to that tax year and be deducted.

Note: David Haley and / or www.DavidHaleyMortgage.com  cannot provide tax advice. Taxpayers should consult their tax advisor to ascertain if they are eligible to take this deduction. The answers to these questions are based on an interpretation of the language of the statute, the Joint Committee on Taxation’s Technical Explanation of the statutory language, and present law. The Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) will issue guidance interpreting the new provision, and could reach different conclusions for some of the issues raised


Brianna C. Avatar
Truly amazing process, support, & communication, so grateful for the guidance in a process that seemed so scary in the beginning, to feeling confident as a first time home buyer! Thank you!
[read more]
B. C. 3/08/2025
Brianna C. Avatar
Truly amazing process, support, & communication, so grateful for the guidance in a process that seemed so scary in the beginning, to feeling confident as a first time home buyer! Thank you!
[read more]
B. C. 3/07/2025
Prowler156 Avatar
They're great working with people and their timely manner and they're pretty awesome
[read more]
P. 3/04/2025
Prowler156 Avatar
They're great working with people and their timely manner and they're pretty awesome
[read more]
P. 2/27/2025
Tim B. Avatar
I'd like to give a huge shoutout to David for being nothing short of amazing while buying my first home. Not only did he answer every question quickly, there were few questions in the first place because he was very thorough, but also explained everything in such a way that made sense. He helped move everything along quickly and efficiently. He was very personable and made me feel at ease about the whole process. Definitely will recommend him to all my friends and family.
[read more]
T. B. 1/30/2025
Kayla G. Avatar
David is absolutely fantastic and has been such a blessing to work with throughout the process of buying our new home! He really breaks everything down for you, makes you feel confident without any questions left unanswered and works quickly to help you make your dreams a reality! Can't recommend enough!
[read more]
K. G. 1/30/2025
  • 1
  • 2
  • 11
  • >

Schedule a Consultation

The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.